22 Words

22 Words

Why Catcher in the Rye isn’t a movie.

Letters of Note posts a 1957 letter from Salinger cordially, yet resolutely, explaining why he’ll (probably) never sell rights to his book.

salinger letter 1

Click to enlarge

(via Wesley Hill)

Category: Literature

9 Responses

  1. 1
    Lowell Stoltzfus says:

    Compelling reasons why good books seldom make good movies.

  2. 2

    I love the closing line: “My mail from producers has mostly been hell.”

    When I think of Catcher as a movie I think of DiCaprio in “The Basketball Diaries”. Who knows, he still looks so young he might be able to pull off a good Holden.

  3. 3

    He’s right, of course. It’s barely coherent, let alone interesting, as a story, if you take the personality of the narrator away. The whole Catcher experience hinges on dramatic monologue. Soliloquy, though it can be engaging in small bursts in the theatre, is grim in film.

  4. 4
    Laura says:

    Agreed. It’s very refreshing to know there is at least one author who isn’t a total sell-out

    If the part had to be cast, though, I’m thinking Adam Brody.

  5. 5
    Chelsea Bass says:

    Well, he certainly convinced me that it would be a bad idea.

  6. 6
    EmilyB says:

    I love this book but agree it would be a horrible movie. I hope they never make one; I really think it would be awful without Holden as he is in the novel.

  7. 7
    abbey says:

    I wonder what if he might feel less vehement if he could see the way today’s film makers work. Creativity in the film industry has increased so much since 1957.

  8. 8
    Idhrendur says:

    While I disliked Catcher in the Rye (it probably deserves a reread), I’m glad to see an author stick to his guns on this point.

  9. 9
    Idhrendur says:

    90 years until it enters the public domain (well, in the US).

    Perhaps the only time I’ve liked how long copyright lasts.

Leave a Reply

Subscribe to 22 Words

  

   

Sponsors

Categories

Reader Recommendations

Some of the books and music that you, the readers, have recommended here over time:

Twitter Recommendations