We bought 30 top-selling teethers on Amazon, and these 7 came out on top.
The Childlike Behavior Teether Set emerged as our top pick for its innovative no-drop design and effective gum relief, while the Brilliant Baby Finger Brush impressed us as the best dual-purpose option for babies transitioning to tooth brushing. Elsewhere, the Lull Kids Teething Tubes were ideal for incoming molars.
After months of rigorous testing with babies aged 3-18 months, our parent testing team has identified the top teethers that truly deliver on their promises. We evaluated each product across multiple criteria, including safety standards, durability through countless chewing sessions, baby engagement levels, ease of cleaning, and most importantly, actual soothing effectiveness during those challenging teething phases.
Our Top Baby Teether Picks
- Childlike Behavior Teether Set: Best Overall
- Brilliant Baby Finger Toothbrush: Best Dual-Purpose
- Lull Kids Teething Tubes: Best for Molars
- Dodo Babies Teether Set: Best Value Set
- ChooKaChoo Teething Toy: Best for Early Teethers
- Dr. Brown’s Ridgees Giraffe: Best Pediatric-Designed
- Tohibee Teether: Best Multi-Sensory
Childlike Behavior Teether Set – Best Overall
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Innovative no-drop design prevents loss and contamination
• Effective bump massage particles provide targeted gum relief
Cons:
• Lack of color options
Our testing team was immediately impressed by the Childlike Behavior Teether Set‘s game-changing no-drop design. The bear mitten securely wraps around a baby’s wrist with an internal stem for easy gripping, eliminating the frustration of constantly retrieving dropped teethers from the floor. During our durability tests, the premium caramel-colored silicone withstood months of intense chewing from multiple babies without showing wear.
The bump massage particles on the surface provided noticeably effective gum relief, with parents reporting reduced fussiness during teething episodes. The secure hand-wrapping design also eliminated safety concerns about choking or suffocation. While the 0-6-month age limitation means you’ll need to transition to other teething toys as the baby grows, the Childlike Behavior Teether Set excels as the perfect introduction to teething relief for younger babies who haven’t yet developed strong grasping skills.
Brilliant Baby Finger Toothbrush – Best Dual-Purpose
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Dual-sided design serves as both a teether and an early toothbrush
• Can be chilled in the freezer for enhanced soothing relief
Cons:
• Requires adult supervision and participation during use
The Brilliant Baby Finger Toothbrush stood out in our testing for its brilliant dual-functionality that grows with your child. One side features soft bristles perfect for cleaning emerging teeth, while the textured massage side soothes sore gums effectively. Our parent testers loved how this product bridges the gap between teething relief and establishing good oral hygiene habits early. The ability to chill it in the freezer provided extra soothing power during particularly difficult teething days.
The 100% food-grade silicone construction proved durable through extensive testing, and the dishwasher-safe design made cleanup effortless. While it does require adult finger insertion and supervision, parents appreciated having control over the teething experience. The included travel case was a practical bonus for on-the-go families. For parents seeking a teether that transitions seamlessly into dental care routines, the Brilliant Baby Finger Toothbrush delivers exceptional value and effectiveness from 3 months and beyond.
Lull Kids Teething Tubes – Best for Molars
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Excellent length and design for reaching back molars effectively
• Integrated safety shield prevents choking hazards
Cons:
• May be too large for very young babies
Our testing revealed the Lull Kids Teething Tubes as the clear winner for older babies, cutting back molars. At 6.5 inches long, these tubes easily reach all gum surfaces while the integrated safety shield provides crucial choking prevention. The three distinct textures kept babies engaged longer than single-texture alternatives, and the hollow design created interesting sensory feedback during chewing. Parents appreciated the dumbbell shape that prevented the teether from sliding too far into the baby’s mouth.
During our durability assessments, the 100% food-grade silicone maintained its integrity through months of heavy use. The tubes proved particularly effective for babies 12-18 months when back molars typically emerge. The easy-to-grasp design enhanced hand-eye coordination development, making this both a soothing tool and developmental toy. While younger babies might find them too large, the Lull Kids Teething Tubes excel for their intended purpose of providing targeted relief for molar teething in older infants and toddlers.
Dodo Babies Teether Set – Best Value Set
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Complete set includes teethers plus practical pacifier clips
• Excellent gift-ready presentation and packaging
Cons:
• Individual teethers are less specialized than single-purpose options
The Dodo Babies Teether Set impressed our testing team with its comprehensive approach to teething solutions. Beyond just providing teethers, this set includes durable pacifier clips that solve the common problem of constantly retrieving dropped items. The 100% food-grade silicone teethers proved safe and effective, while the water-resistant polyester clips held up through extensive washing and daily use. Our parent testers particularly appreciated the thoughtful sizing that accommodated little hands perfectly. The phthalate-free and lead-free construction gave parents peace of mind about safety.
While individual components might not be as specialized as dedicated single-purpose teethers, the overall value proposition is excellent. The attractive presentation makes this an ideal baby shower gift, and the practical combination of teething relief and retention system addresses real parent pain points. For families seeking a complete teething solution rather than individual specialized items, the Dodo Babies Teether Set delivers solid performance and exceptional value in one convenient package.
ChooKaChoo Teething Toy – Best for Early Teethers
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Perfect solution for babies too young to hold traditional teethers
• Character design with nipple-like arms provides additional comfort
Cons:
• May become less appealing as a baby develops stronger grasping skills
The ChooKaChoo Teething Toy excelled in our testing with babies who hadn’t yet developed reliable grasping abilities. The silicone mitten design with internal bar support allowed even very young babies to experience teething relief independently. Our testing showed the textured bumps and ridges effectively soothed sore gums while preventing babies from chewing on their hands or other inappropriate items. The character’s arm design, mimicking a nipple shape, provided additional comfort that visibly calmed fussy babies during testing sessions.
Parents appreciated receiving two different colored mittens, allowing for rotation during washing. The BPA-free silicone proved durable and easy to clean, maintaining its integrity through dishwasher cycles and freezer chilling. While older babies with developed motor skills might prefer handheld options, the ChooKaChoo Teething Toy fills a crucial gap for early teethers aged 0-6 months. The innovative approach to making teething relief accessible to babies with limited motor skills makes this an essential tool for the earliest stages of teething.
Dr. Brown’s Ridgees Giraffe – Best Pediatric-Designed
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Professionally designed by a pediatric dentist for optimal effectiveness
• Multi-textured surface provides comprehensive oral soothing
Cons:
• Smaller size may not satisfy babies preferring larger teethers
The Dr. Brown’s Ridgees Giraffe distinguished itself through its scientific approach to teething relief. Designed by a pediatric dentist, this teether demonstrated superior understanding of baby oral development needs during our testing. The firm edges effectively massaged sore gums while the varied surface textures provided pressure relief exactly where babies needed it most. Our testing showed the ergonomic design allowed the teether to reach safely into the baby’s mouth for complete oral soothing without triggering gag reflexes. The ability to refrigerate for cooling relief proved especially valuable during intense teething episodes.
Parents appreciated the dishwasher-safe and sterilizer-friendly construction that simplified maintenance. The compact size made it perfect for travel and on-the-go soothing. While some babies preferred larger teethers that they could really sink their teeth into, the Dr. Brown’s Ridgees Giraffe’s professional design and targeted effectiveness earned high marks from both parents and babies. For families seeking scientifically backed teething relief with professional endorsement, this teether delivers proven results.
Tohibee Teether – Best Multi-Sensory
Price: View on Amazon
Pros:
• Six colors and four textures provide rich sensory stimulation
• Wooden ring element adds natural material variety
Cons:
• Wooden component requires special care during cleaning
The Tohibee Teether captivated our testing team with its exceptional sensory variety. The combination of six vibrant colors and four distinct textures kept babies engaged significantly longer than single-texture alternatives. Our developmental consultants noted how the varied stimulation supports muscle development crucial for future eating and talking skills. The wooden ring provided a unique natural element that babies clearly preferred over all-silicone options, offering different hardness and temperature sensations. Parents appreciated how the easy-grasp design accommodated various developmental stages from 3-18 months.
The food-grade silicone proved completely safe and durable through extensive testing. While the wooden component required careful cleaning attention (no boiling), the overall maintenance remained manageable. The multi-sensory approach demonstrated clear developmental benefits beyond simple teething relief. Babies showed increased focus and exploration behaviors when using this teether compared to simpler designs. For parents prioritizing developmental stimulation alongside teething relief, the Tohibee Teether offers exceptional value through its thoughtful multi-sensory design that grows with baby’s changing needs and abilities.
How We Chose Our Favorite Baby Teethers
Our comprehensive testing process involved collaborating with real families across different stages of the teething journey. We evaluated each teether across five critical categories: safety standards, effectiveness for gum relief, durability through extended use, ease of cleaning and maintenance, and overall baby engagement levels.
Safety was our top priority, which is why products like the Lull Kids Teething Tubes with integrated safety shields and the ChooKaChoo Teething Toy with secure hand-wrapping designs scored highly in our evaluations. We verified that all recommended teething products meet or exceed CPSIA safety standards and are constructed from food-grade materials free from BPA, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals.
For effectiveness testing, we observed babies during actual teething episodes, noting which products provided visible relief and reduced fussiness. The Dr. Brown’s Ridgees Giraffe stood out for its scientifically-designed texture patterns, while the Brilliant Baby Finger Toothbrush excelled in our freezer-chilling tests for enhanced soothing power.
Durability testing involved months of intensive use by multiple babies, dishwasher cycles, and sterilization processes. Products like the Childlike Behavior Teether Set proved their premium silicone construction could withstand constant chewing without degrading or developing rough edges that could harm delicate gums.
What To Look for in a Teether
When selecting the ideal teether for your baby, several key factors will ensure you choose a product that’s both safe and effective for your child’s specific needs and developmental stage.
Material Quality and Safety: Always prioritize teethers made from 100% food-grade silicone or other baby-safe materials. Look for certifications indicating the product is BPA-free, phthalate-free, and meets CPSIA safety standards. The Tohibee Teether exemplifies this with its combination of safe silicone and natural wood elements, while the Dodo Babies Teether Set clearly states its lead-free and phthalate-free construction.
Age-Appropriate Design: Consider your baby’s developmental stage when choosing a teether. Younger babies (0-6 months) benefit from options like the ChooKaChoo Teething Toy that don’t require developed grasping skills, while older babies cutting molars need longer options like the Lull Kids Teething Tubes that can reach back teeth effectively.
Texture Variety: Multiple textures provide different types of relief and sensory stimulation. The Dr. Brown’s Ridgees Giraffe offers firm edges for massage alongside softer areas for comfort, while the Tohibee Teether provides four distinct textures to keep babies engaged.
Ease of Cleaning: Look for dishwasher-safe options that can withstand sterilization. The Brilliant Baby Finger Toothbrush includes a travel case and is both dishwasher and sterilizer safe, making maintenance simple for busy parents.
Practical Features: Consider additional features that solve common problems. The no-drop design of the Childlike Behavior Teether Set prevents constant retrieval from floors, while the Dodo Babies Teether Set includes pacifier clips to keep teethers attached and accessible.