Charlie and The Chocolate Factory is one of the most beloved childhood classics, but, when the Tim Burton helmed remake came in 2005, it begged the question: which Charlie and the Chocolate Factory adaption is better?
Well, it seems we finally have the answer…
For most of us, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is a staple childhood classic.
The story of greed, gluttony, and a giant chocolate factory… What’s not to love?
Critically acclaimed children’s author, Roald Dahl, who also brought us classics such as Matilda and The Witches, first wrote the story of Charlie Bucket and his quest to visit Willy Wonka’s infamous chocolate factory back in 1964.
So, a movie adaptation was made in 1971, 7 years on from its initial publication.
Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory was the first attempt at bringing the children’s book to life…
And we saw as Hollywood legend, Gene Wilder, portrayed the role of the charismatic and slightly eccentric Willy Wonka.
Wilder completely killed it.
And therefore set the bar pretty high for any future adaption and remake attempts.
In the decades following on from its release, filmmakers far and wide left the tale of Willy Wonka firmly alone.
Because who can follow on from such a masterpiece?
And the darker, more gothic adaptation, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory was released in 2005.
And, despite the edgy remake being a far cry from the 1971 version, he did a pretty good job at it.
A TV series is said to be in the works from Taika Waititi, the Academy Award-winning filmmaker and brains behind the controversial Jojo Rabbit.
You can get all the details on the upcoming project at the end…
No matter how many times you watch, they never seem to get old.
And opinions seem to always been divided on the matter.
For others, a more gothic take gave the story a unique edge.
After both the movies were added to Netflix’s growing movie catalog, Ladbible decided to put out a poll to pit both adaptations against each other.
…the original, of course!
With the original flick gaining a whopping seventy-two percent of the votes.
And opinions on the matter came in very strong.
For most viewers, there really was no contest.
And felt the gothic undertone was just too creepy for them.
And despite liking Burton’s 2005 remake, the original still came out on top.
Do you agree with the poll? Which movie do you think is better?
While you mull that one over, scroll on for all the details about the upcoming Charlie and the Chocolate Factory series…