Pet Products I Ordered From Chewy and Will Keep Buying Over and Over Again

Share on Facebook

There are only a few things I’m sure of in life, but one of them is that my pets are picky. Like, so, so, so picky. They like a particular type of food, treats, and toys, and sometimes it can be hard to know what they’re like best. But don’t worry, I’ve done all the hard work for you by compiling the absolute best pet products Chewy has to offer.

These are the products my pets use and love, and they’re the ones I come back to time and time again. I even have Chewy’s handy auto-ship option turned on for most of these items because my animals can’t go a month without them.

We hope you find these products as awesome as we do. Just an FYI: We are a participant in the Amazon affiliate program, and Brainjolt may receive a share of sales from links on this page. Prices on Amazon fluctuate so anything mentioned below might change as soon we publish it!

Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy

Frisco Cat Tracks Butterfly Cat Toy “I just finished putting this together less than 20 minutes ago and it’s already my 9-week old kitten’s favorite thing since canned food. The balls move nice and easily so she can play by herself and it even included an extra butterfly for the top for when she inevitably chews it off. This toy is awesome, and in general Chewy and their customer service are amazing. Thank you!” – Hillary

ZippyPaws Skinny Peltz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toys, 3-pack

ZippyPaws Skinny Peltz No Stuffing Squeaky Plush Dog Toys, 3-pack “I have 2 dachshunds that can destroy a toy in 1 second flat! They can destroy any heavy-duty toy! I ordered these as they have no stuffing and I figured at least I wouldn’t have to pick up stuffing after they destroyed the toys. I was surprised that after 4 days they are still intact!!!” – SpeedyMom

K9 Natural Beef Feast with Hoki Oil Freeze-Dried Puppy Food Topper

K9 Natural Beef Feast with Hoki Oil Freeze-Dried Puppy Food Topper “I have a very picky puppy and he loves this. I am so happy he actually likes something that is good for him! Thank you.” – Gypsy

Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy

Yeowww! Catnip Yellow Banana Cat Toy “I highly recommend this toy. I have never seen she reacted like that with the catnip for 6 years. When I brought the Chewy box at home, she started rubbing on the box. I thought she smells her food, but nope. She smells that catnip banana! Even though she made some holes on her toy with her teeth only in 10mins, I am extremely happy I got it from Chewy. Please do not hesitate to buy it!” – Mosu

Nylabone DuraChew Textured Ring Flavor Medley Dog Toy, X-Large

Nylabone DuraChew Textured Ring Flavor Medley Dog Toy, X-Large “I am a rescuer who fosters large to extra large breeds. I am always looking for sturdy chews, toys, etc. Chewy suggested the Durabone Dura Chew Textured Ring for heavy chewers so I decided to give it a try. They are heavy, sturdy and the dogs LOVE them! They are the perfect crate companion to keep them busy when we’re away from home. We have heavy chewers (who destroy toys in minutes) so these are perfect for them and last a long time! Finally, a toy that lasts!” – DHRDogs

Frisco 21-in Sisal Cat Scratching Post with Toy

Frisco 21-in Sisal Cat Scratching Post with Toy “We have a two-storey home, with a scratching post upstairs. But we found that too often the cats wanted to scratch when downstairs and without a second scratching post, our furniture was taking a hit. We didn’t want to put a tower in the living room, but this is perfect! Tall enough to do the job, but shorter than the top of our couch. It looks nice, too, and is very well made.” – Ardith

AvoDerm Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Recipe Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food

AvoDerm Chicken Meal & Brown Rice Recipe Large Breed Adult Dry Dog Food “I have fed my golden retriever Avoderm (switching between large breed and triple protein blends) for 4 years and he does wonderful on it! He is always getting compliments on his coat and our vet comments that we feed him “quality food.” Hoping Chewy can keep the large breed blend in stock because we definitely prefer to purchase from Chewy!” – Brittany

All Kind Wave Cat Scratcher, Tropical Palms

All Kind Wave Cat Scratcher, Tropical Palms “This arrived in record time. The tomcat kitten has already torn off one of the side panels. They love it. This the second one we are on. And won’t be the last. The times I have spoken with customer service were great!!” – Nana

American Journey Turkey & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

American Journey Turkey & Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Cat Food “My cat is the pickiest cat I know. He’s always been very specific about what kind of canned food he eats, and I could never get him to actually eat dry kibble. I saw this food and figured I’d give it a go, thinking he would like the more natural meaty taste. To my relief, he absolutely loves it. This the only dry food that he will willingly eat. He devours it! I will definitely be buying more. He loves it so much, I added it to my auto-ship.” – Mr. Picky

Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Mature Consult Small Breed Dry Dog Food

Royal Canin Veterinary Diet Mature Consult Small Breed Dry Dog Food “My dog loves this food. There was no transition time. He took to it immediately and ate every last crumb. And so good for him according to our vet recommendation.” – Rescue Mom

Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy

Ethical Pet Wool Pom Poms with Catnip Cat Toy “Ok, so it’s been about 5 hours since we received our latest chewy box and opened up the new toys and treats….not sure if I did the right thing to buy my cats these pom poms because I have a feeling they are going to keep us up all night! They have been playing non-stop! I try to hide the pom poms but they find them and run all over the place! These pom poms are also the perfect size for my cat who loves to play fetch, and he loves the texture!” – Pumeros

Royal Canin Small Adult Wet Dog Food

Royal Canin Small Adult Wet Dog Food “My finicky toy poodle Pepe loved this food. I mixed it in with his dry food and he ate everything! He used to get indigestion with another product, but not anymore. I love that he gets excited about eating. Thank you Chewy for this product!” – Susie

Stella & Chewy’s Chick Chick Chicken Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food

Stella & Chewy’s Chick Chick Chicken Dinner Morsels Freeze-Dried Raw Cat Food “A “kitty rescue” friend recommended this as her cats LOVE it. My 8 rescues turned their noses up at first but after refusing it for a couple of days they decided to give it a try. Now they think it is rather yummy and 5 of the 8 love it.” – Kitty Haven

Go! Daily Defence Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food

Go! Daily Defence Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food “I mix in the wet food couple times a week with the dry kibble of the same brand and also use the wet food to hide the monthly flea and tick medication. This is a huge winner. Ripley eats both the chicken and the beef. The beef seems to be his favorite, but both get devoured. Smells good, you can see the peas and veggies. Nice and chunky. Ripley’s fur has a nice sheen since we switched over.” – Ripley’s Mom

Multipet Lamb Chop Squeaky Plush Dog Toy

Multipet Lamb Chop Squeaky Plush Dog Toy “Winston, our male Cardigan Corgi bonded with this toy from the second he saw it. He wouldn’t let it go for the first hour and then it has become his toy of choice at every playtime. He even puts his chin on it and takes naps. Our Pembroke Corgi, Gracie wants it too and he will not have it. She loses every tug of war game with this toy. When Gracie catches it, it’s hilarious to see her running back with it in her mouth and it’s about as big as she is. Thank you Chewy for providing hours of fun for our fur children with the great choices of toys.” – Gracie

Purina Pro Plan Bright Mind Adult 7+ Beef & Brown Rice Entree Wet Dog Food

Purina Pro Plan Bright Mind Adult 7+ Beef & Brown Rice Entree Wet Dog Food “This is for real! I read all the reviews with skepticism but my 9 yo Shih Tzu / Cav mix is mentally having troubles. The behaviorist recommended it, stating it has been well researched. He can’t eat the kibble due to a chicken allergy, so the wet is a great alternative — and he is crazy for it as a topper over his dry. I’m seeing positive changes in just 10 days; he’s perky, silly, playing with the cat, and smiling again. I’m thrilled. Do give it a try.” – WoodysMom

Dr. Lyon’s Pill Pouches Chicken Flavor Dog Treats

Dr. Lyon’s Pill Pouches Chicken Flavor Dog Treats “My dog took her pills very quickly with this. She loved the taste and didn’t notice the medicine. I also like these because they don’t crumble apart when you are molding them if it takes you a few times to cover the pill. We used 2 of them to give her the Trifexis she normally detests and it worked, so I’ll definitely continue to purchase these!” – MegD

FirstMate 50/50 Turkey & Tuna Formula Grain-Free Canned Dog Food

FirstMate 50/50 Turkey & Tuna Formula Grain-Free Canned Dog Food “My little Poodle Mix has had ongoing problems with his stomach. Either he can’t go to the bathroom or his stool is runny. Last year on the recommendation of my local pet store, I started my dog on First Mate. No more problems and he loves the food!!!” – ollieberry

Annamaet Grain-Free Ohana Puppy Formula Dry Dog Food

Annamaet Grain-Free Ohana Puppy Formula Dry Dog Food “My puppy is a finicky Border Collie who would rather play than eat, and he has a very sensitive stomach. He’s 10 months old, and I think we’ve tried at least 10 different foods. Lots of great brands, but he either wouldn’t eat or would get sick on his food. FINALLY – I love this stuff! He loves it, and he eats it like a treat for training. His stomach is also doing much better. I also love that this is a small family company in Pennsylvania.” – BCMom

The Honest Kitchen Meal Booster 99% Chicken Wet Dog Food Topper

The Honest Kitchen Meal Booster 99% Chicken Wet Dog Food Topper “We have two fussy Italian Greyhounds and this is a firm favorite mixed with their other food. One of them would gorge herself silly on it if she could!!” – SB91

Get Naked Dental Health Medium Vanilla Mint Flavor Grain-Free Dog Treats

The best dental health dog treats: Get Naked Dental Health Medium Vanilla Mint Flavor Grain-Free Dog Treats “The scent is pleasing and our dogs love these. We bought the small size first for our 13lb Chiweenie and 22lb poodle mix – they seemed too small and were gone in an instance – so I went up to the medium size. These are perfect – they chew and chew once a week their breath is fresh and the tartar build-up has stopped getting worse.” – MttnGirl123

Nulo Freestyle Grain-Free Salmon Recipe Dog Training Treats

Nulo Freestyle Grain-Free Salmon Recipe Dog Training Treats “My dogs love Nulo. They get excited when they see the bag the treats come in. I feel good about giving them the treats because they are healthy for them.” – Sunny

Better Belly Proteins with Real Lamb Flavor Rawhide Roll Dog Treats

Better Belly Proteins with Real Lamb Flavor Rawhide Roll Dog Treats “These were a little bigger than I thought but oh my goodness do my two Shelties love them. My boy is very fussy and only likes one brand of rawhide rolls. He really needs to chew but turns his head against most everything else…until these arrived. He is obsessed…and since he’s little, it’s lasting him quite some time. My girl is an aggressive chewer so it’s nice to see this lasting a little longer than the typical 15-minute bully stick! She likes trying to pull off the strips of meat on the outside. This is a great addition to our collection of chew options!!” – SheltieMom

Jack & Pup Roasted Beef Knuckle Head Bone Dog Treats

Jack & Pup Roasted Beef Knuckle Head Bone Dog Treats “Finally something my pup won’t demolish in 2 seconds. She chews thru any “long chew” in minutes and these bones have a unique shape that my dog has to work at longer, which also keeps her stimulated while I’m at work. It’s a win-win.” – Ashley

Cesar Classic Loaf in Sauce Grilled Chicken Flavor Multipack Dog Food Trays

Cesar Classic Loaf in Sauce Grilled Chicken Flavor Multipack Dog Food Trays “My lil babies just LOVE this grilled chicken from Cesar. I also get the steak assortment to and mix them up! Very happy!” – Dog Mama

Nature Gnaws Medium Himalayan Yak Cheese Dog Chew Treats

Nature Gnaws Medium Himalayan Yak Cheese Dog Chew Treats “My labrador loves these. Even though he is a large dog I bought medium because you cannot break these to a smaller size. Keeps him occupied longer than anything else. He will lie in the snow to chew on them! And I always take the ends away and put in the microwave for a short time to puff them up so he cannot choke on a small bit. Almost like a two for one.” – ParisHongKong

Royal Canin Boxer Loaf in Sauce Canned Dog Food

Royal Canin Boxer Loaf in Sauce Canned Dog Food “My soon to be 10-year-old Boxer was starting to slow down on his eating. He loves his boxer loaf and it makes it much easier for him to chew!” – Sammy